找回密码
 注册
搜索
查看: 2355|回复: 30

一则MGS4玩家短评(英)

[复制链接]
发表于 2009-3-16 14:49:31 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
Got it and beat it on release date. Got a PS3 for it alone (Although LBP and Killzone 2 will likely be added to the collection).
I&#39m still dwelling on the game itself. I do solidly dislike the plotline. It felt over the top and unnecessary, and overly connected. I am mainly referring to Big Boss at the very end, to Liquid Ocelot&#39s reveal, and who the patriots really were. This all seemed rather inappropriate.
Snake&#39s portrayal was both good and bad. Good in him being old, falling apart, and still trying to go forward. Bad in him being downright stupid occasionally. It felt like he asked a ton of questions, a lot unnecessary.
I felt Raiden was completely demolished. His character fell apart, was written too strongly and hamfistedly to be badass, and generally paled in comparison to his excellent role in MGS2.
The PMCs were on paper an excellent idea. In practice, generally a sideplot at best.
Drebin was a solid character, but relegating him to spit out the BatB corps background was..eh..
Gameplay wise, it excelled in the first and second act. I personally liked the third, but I can feel for people who disliked it. The fourth act was incredible the first time, and is still fairly solid. The fifth act was..confusing. I felt like it was missing a huge chunk.
Yet, it was enjoyable as a whole. A great game.. but not a great MGS game. It almost felt like it needed more time.
And yet, despite all of these opinions, I&#39m still not sure where to place it. It is almost as though MGS2 was wrote into a corner, one Hideo couldn&#39t pull it back (or didn&#39t have the passion to) from. I wasn&#39t expecting aliens or anything incredibly supernatural.. but I was expecting something.. I don&#39t know. Better than &#39The cast of MGS3 and a buncha AIs are the Patriots!&#39 and the extreme reliance on nanomachines.
Any thoughts?

我基本同意
发表于 2009-3-16 15:29:32 | 显示全部楼层
原来LZ和那个作者都这么想…
我的感受没有这么的深刻和理智…但是最基本的想法是,玩完4之后没有得到玩完3的时候那种热泪盈眶的激动,当然得除去重返shadow moses那一章节响起the better is yet to come的时候…
p.s. act 3 really stunned me and i love it~
 楼主| 发表于 2009-3-16 15:39:32 | 显示全部楼层
[quote=Altmann;524258]原来LZ和那个作者都这么想…
我的感受没有这么的深刻和理智…但是最基本的想法是,玩完4之后没有得到玩完3的时候那种热泪盈眶的激动,当然得除去重返shadow moses那一章节响起the better is yet to come的时候…
p.s. act 3 really stunned me and i love it~[/quote]
1.因为4的剧情很烂
2.act4的感动 个人觉得有些刻意
3.act 3从开头到见到eva之前,是mgs4我最喜欢的一段(不知你喜欢是不是因为后面的chase)
发表于 2009-3-16 15:49:01 | 显示全部楼层
[quote=0479;524259]1.因为4的剧情很烂
2.act4的感动 个人觉得有些刻意
3.act 3从开头到见到eva之前,是mgs4我最喜欢的一段(不知你喜欢是不是因为后面的chase)[/quote]
哈的半一咯的自重
发表于 2009-3-16 15:49:49 | 显示全部楼层
1. 原来如此,原来还是有人质疑4的剧情的…我看着那么的的满分和排山倒海的好评,于是一直在怀疑自己的理解能力…
2. 不论是不是刻意,我实在是被感动了…后来每次玩到这里的第一件事就是开ipod不断重播这首曲子
3. 不是那个chase。那个跟踪新意十足(恶搞也不少),加之本来就喜欢古老欧洲的肃杀气氛。只可惜这一节虽然好玩,但古典的风格有点和其它章节的近未来风格格格不入
 楼主| 发表于 2009-3-16 15:55:12 | 显示全部楼层
[quote=The Sorrow;524261]哈的半一咯的自重[/quote]
怎么就能写成这样呢= =
engrish理解不能

[quote=Altmann;524262]1. 原来如此,原来还是有人质疑4的剧情的…我看着那么的的满分和排山倒海的好评,于是一直在怀疑自己的理解能力…
3. 对的。那个chase新意十足(恶搞也不少),加之本来就喜欢古老欧洲的肃杀气氛。只可惜这一节虽然好玩,但古典的风格有点和其它章节的近未来风格格格不入[/quote]
1.这个以前在4区讨论过的
满分怕都是非mgs fan的critic打的吧
个人认为是最差一作,mgs味道尽失

3.我最喜欢的是尾行那一段
film noir + retro-future

ps*您可是老潜艇了
发表于 2009-3-16 17:12:56 | 显示全部楼层
那个跟踪新意十足(恶搞也不少)
[/SIZE]
哦哦哦单论这句话你就该来看看此文了(看完之后你会立马发现...小岛就这些套路了)*[/SIZE]
http://www.thesnakesoup.org/?sec ... p;content=mgs4dumb2
发表于 2009-3-16 19:07:54 | 显示全部楼层
[quote=0479;524265]怎么就能写成这样呢= =
engrish理解不能
[/quote]

“我类哇哈的半一咯的都心~~”
发表于 2009-3-16 19:47:52 | 显示全部楼层
[quote=The Sorrow;524277]“我类哇哈的半一咯的都心~~”[/quote]
SORROW不要在专区灌水啃。
发表于 2009-3-16 19:53:22 | 显示全部楼层
对于MGS4,04批评剧情韵味尽失,的的批评流程乐趣太少,这更激起了我想亲手玩MGS4的念头。

看着最近CAPCOM的生化危机5,有人大声叫好,有人嗤之以鼻。不知不觉之中,我们在改变,游戏也在改变,世界也在改变。
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

Archiver|手机版|小黑屋|MGCN谍海游龙

GMT+8, 2026-8-16 09:34 , Processed in 0.039049 second(s), 16 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X5.0

© 2001-2026 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表